Juan Soriano
Mexican, 1920 - 2006View Objects By Juan Soriano >>
Fragile Demon: Juan Soriano in Mexico, 1935 to 1950
Juan Soriano (1920-2006) had a distinguished career as a painter, printmaker, and sculptor that lasted from 1934 until virtually the time of his death. A younger contemporary of such famous Mexican artists as Diego Rivera, Frida Kahlo, and José Clemente Orozco, Soriano, seen here in a dreamily evocative self-portrait drawing from 1946 (Self-Portrait, Museo Soumaya, Mexico City),1 is celebrated at home but is much less well known abroad. There has not been, until now, a show dedicated to his early years in his native Guadalajara and Mexico City, where he lived from 1935 to 1951 before departing for an extended period in Europe. This volume is published on the occasion of the first monographic exhibition of Soriano's work in a major U.S. institution, and the Philadelphia Museum of Art is an appropriate organizer of such an effort for several reasons. In the 1940s, the Museum's Curator of Paintings Henry Clifford was actively involved in collecting modern Mexican painting, and he was instrumental in acquiring Philadelphia's four Sorianos from this period, the largest number in any U.S. institution. One of these, the compellingly mysterious Dead Girl of 1938 (see Philadelphia Museum of Art, 1947-29-3), has become a virtually iconic image, appearing in books and exhibitions as the quintessential example of its genre. The Museum's other works by Soriano--Still Life of 1942 (see Philadelphia Museum of Art, 1951-120-4), Girl with a Mask of 1945 (1947-24-1), and Girl with Bouquet of 1946 (1957-94-1)--are representative of the principal themes of his art during these years. The Museum's strong collection of colonial and twentieth century Mexican painting, long-standing commitment to exhibiting Latin American art,2 and distinguished holdings of international modern art similarly make it an especially fitting venue for the project. Why is Juan Soriano not better known outside Mexico? One reason may be that he did not have consistent gallery representation as an emerging artist. Although he was on cordial terms with the renowned art dealer Inés Amor of the Galería de Arte Mexicano in Mexico City, he had only two solo shows there in the 1940s, and he never had a formal contract with the gallery. In contrast to many of his contemporaries, who engaged in aggressive marketing, Soriano was not a self-promoter. Also unlike many of the most successful Mexican painters of the years before and immediately after World War II, his politics were not leftist, and thus he did not receive (nor did he seek) official, public commissions that were so often given to others on the basis of political affiliation. During the 1930s and 1940s, the years to which Philadelphia's works date, Soriano developed a realistic mode of expression in his paintings of children, still lifes, portraits, and allegories. This vision was tinged with what some critics have labeled romanticism, and others have dubbed "Surrealist tendencies." While there are a number of monographs and specialized studies of his work, Soriano has yet to be the subject of the type of revisionist appraisal that a younger generation of Mexican and non-Mexican scholars has focused on many other key figures of this period.3 Looking anew at this important modern master with a view toward situating him more securely within the larger panorama of his time, both within Mexico and abroad, will serve to unveil new, long-needed critical perspectives on his work.Soriano in Guadalajara
Reminiscing about his early years Soriano stated:Nothing affected my life more than those first fifteen years in Guadalajara. Nothing that has happened to me since has been more important than [the state of] Jalisco. I learned all the oral traditions. My father and mother wanted to make me into a son of the Revolution. They smothered me with their memories of battles, . . . cries of the clarinet, [military] camps, cheers for the Revolution, locomotives, and attempted assassinations.4Although he rarely spent time in Guadalajara after leaving for Mexico City in 1935, the culture of this conservative city served as the basis for many of the themes and details of his work during the period under consideration here. Soriano was born on August 18, 1920 (the year that marked the end of the Mexican Revolution), into a family of thirteen aunts and four sisters. He was the youngest child and the only male sibling. His father, Rafael Rodríguez Soriano, was a minor politician who had fought in the Revolution and whose wife, Amalia Montoya, had followed him into battle. Soriano was a solitary child who spent long periods in convalescence from his many illnesses. His sisters, especially Rosa and Martha, were instrumental in encouraging him to express his fantasies in drawing and painting. Martha, ten years older than Juan, played a vital role in his life for many years, serving as muse and facilitator of her brother's earliest connections with local artists, most importantly Jesús Reyes Ferreira (known as Chucho Reyes). Reyes was a multifaceted personality who collected antiques, sold nineteenth-century Mexican paintings (including some fakes manufactured by the students of his informal classes, among them Soriano5), and ultimately established a distinguished career as an artist, usually of small, rapidly painted images of animals, skeletons, or fantastic creatures in ink or watercolor on rice paper. Chucho Reyes fostered the young painter's interest in Mexican folk art as well as the popular traditions of nineteenth-century portraiture. It was Reyes who introduced Soriano to the world of art beyond the confines of the city and country. His substantial library contained many books on the masters of the Italian and Northern Renaissance. He subscribed to newspapers and magazines from abroad that carried images of the latest trends in art, all of which proved to be revelatory for the precocious child. Reyes also purchased some of Soriano's first paintings and drawings in order to resell them.6 The theme of at least one of these paintings, a dead child, became a subject later repeated by Soriano in a number of his works (see Philadelphia Museum of Art, 1947-29-3; The Dead Girl, 1944, Gilcrease Museum, Tulsa, Oklahoma; The Dead Girl {The Wake}, 1946, Private collection).7 Reyes was not the only person with whom the young Soriano studied in Guadalajara. His sister Martha enrolled him in the drawing classes of the local painter Francisco Rodríguez, whose studio, known as Evolución, was frequented by Agustín Lazo, Jesús Guerrero Galván, and others. After Soriano's move to Mexico City he kept up his contact with these and other artists from Jalisco and especially with the Guadalajara contingent, who in the 1940s formed a group with a particular visual ethos that the art historian Olivier Debroise has described as "a lyrical vein, a poetic inspiration which is a bit old-fashioned (provincial . . . if we take away its negative connotations), which some will soon misinterpret as Surrealism."8 Inés Amor later supported many of these artists and made her Galería de Arte Mexicano a focal point for their artistic production.9 The cultural critic Carlos Monsiváis lyrically evoked the artistic atmosphere of Guadalajara in the earlier twentieth century, which continued to nourish the Jalisco group even after their move away from the city. Writing specifically of Soriano, he stated:
Guadalajara was the center for the preservation of an aesthetic (called by [the poet Ramón] López Velarde), la patria íntima, which rejected the innovations of the capital of the Republic, judging them to be heretical, reverting [instead] to a past of colors, melodies, architectonic forms, oral culture, refrains, events, objects. Soriano attributes his creative predisposition and his scheme of values to the city of his birth.10The reverberating influences of Soriano's native city included the religious processions that marked the ecclesiastical calendar, the home altars that were inevitable features of virtually every domestic setting, and especially the colonial architecture that still abounded in his youth. The artist recalled his attraction to these buildings--including churches, convents, and baronial residences--and their interiors: "I used to love to go into those colonial buildings, especially the churches. I would often wait until most of the people were leaving and then spend as long as possible looking at the altarpieces and the sculptures when the daylight was gradually disappearing."11 This interest in seventeenth and eighteenth-century art became more pronounced when the artist moved to Mexico City. His compositions of the 1940s often include figures of angels, both lifelike and sculptural, which even find their way into some of Soriano's formal portraits, such as the 1948 Portrait of Ignacio and Sofía Bernal (Private collection), in which the archaeologist of Monte Alban, Oaxaca, is seen with his wife against an open window with the bell towers of the Mexico City cathedral clearly visible and a large angel standing on the window ledge. The Guadalajara painter Alfonso Michel was the first established artist to appreciate Soriano's watercolors when they were brought to his attention by his sister Martha.12 There are several surviving portraits of the many that Soriano did of his sisters and their Guadalajara friends. The 1934 Portrait of Martha (Private collection), which was painted in Rodríguez's studio, is a curious depiction (not unlike the Hollywood publicity shots of starlets of the time) of the upper portion of the sitter's body against a muddy yellow background. Her head is at the right, and at the left is a wedge of the blue table on which there are several books, one with the partially concealed title La Farsa. There is also a bottle of tequila because, as Soriano said, "Martha, like everyone else, drank a lot."13 The artist explained that in this work "I sought . . . to produce a very strict composition. I liked to practice . . . dividing the space geometrically. . . . I had never thought that Cubism was of interest to me; I didn't like its bottles and Cubist guitars, but when I go back and look at these first portraits I see that even though I wasn't conscious of it, there is a Cubist influence."14 Painted in March 1935, the Portrait of a Girl (Fundación Juan Soriano y Marek Keller A.C., Mexico City) is a similar but somewhat more complex study of spatial division, with its background separated into two distinct, almost equal zones, both dark blue. The floor is a triangular shape of pink and the table a yellow rectangle. The girl herself is formed by interlocking, tubular shapes. On the table there are fruits, a flower, a bunch of grapes, a box, and a small papier-mâché doll, all resting somewhat uneasily on the surface. While it would be fair to call these early pictures examples of juvenilia, they are significant indicators of the styles and techniques that Soriano was developing while still in Guadalajara and that continued to be useful to him later. His interest in the popular or folk forms to which he had been introduced by Chucho Reyes is evidenced in the 1935 portrait by the flat colors and elemental shapes of the objects on the table. We are equally reminded of the drawing method based on popular forms derived by the painter Adolfo Best Maugard and disseminated throughout Mexico (and abroad) through a state-published manual known to most children and art students in this period.15 Yet Soriano ultimately digested and transformed these (perhaps even unconscious) sources to produce an art in the later 1930s and throughout the 1940s that, while making reference to certain visual foundations, radiated a high degree of sophistication and originality. The youthful painter's "big break" came in 1934, when Soriano was brought to the attention of a group of well-established artists by Francisco Rodríguez's exhibition of his students' work at the Museo Regional de Guadalajara. During a visit to the show the photographer Lola Alvarez Bravo and the painters María Izquierdo and José Chávez Morado were struck by Soriano's paintings (many of which were on modest size pieces of cardboard that a tailor uncle had given him) and urged the boy to broaden his horizons by moving to Mexico City. When in the capital, Soriano remained close to both Alvarez Bravo and Izquierdo. Lola Alvarez Bravo became the artist's muse and model for a number of key works of the late 1930s and 1940s (a role that Guadalupe Marín, former wife of Diego Rivera, would play in the 1960s). Among these is the evocative 1944 double portrait of Lola Alvarez Bravo with Juan Soriano as a Child (Private collection). Alvarez Bravo took many of the most significant photographic portraits of the artist, while also employing his image in some experimental pieces, such as her photomontages of the 1940s.16 Izquierdo, whose work of the 1930s bears a marked similarity in subject and style to that of Soriano, also continued to play a pivotal role in his life. She painted one of the best known and most beautiful portraits of the young artist in 1939 (now in the Museo Andrés Blaisten, Mexico City), which was included (along with other likenesses of the painter's literary and artistic friends) in her solo show organized the same year at the Galería de Arte Mexicano.17 Soriano said to the writer Elena Poniatowska that "María Izquierdo was fundamental [to me. She was] bewitching and had a very particular sense of humor. What a fabulous face of an antique sculpture!"18
Soriano in Mexico City
Soriano and the Literary Vanguard
On August 15, 1945, three days before Juan Soriano's twenty-fifth birthday, the Mexican poet, essayist, critic, and editor Octavio G. Barreda published a profile of the artist in his literary journal El hijo pródigo. Simply entitled "Juan Soriano," it offered a sketch of what the writer considered the artist's main physical and artistic traits. It begins by stating: "In 1920 was born this fragile, sickly demon." It then continues to evoke the times and artistic temperament of Mexico at the outset of the third decade of the century through an ironic allusion to the principal players in the country's postrevolutionary artistic scene, including the so-called Tres Grandes: Diego Rivera, José Clemente Orozco, and David Alfaro Siqueiros. "Soriano was born," Barreda wrote, "precisely at the moment when the grave and corpulent angels and archangels installed and opened to the public the dramatic panorama of our revolutionary renaissance. There, amidst that cardboard world, that [world of] stage scenery, of great barbarous curtains, of gigantic Wagnerian backdrops, this thin devil, this strange impertinent creature first saw the light of day."19 After hinting at the growing conflicts within the Mexican art world, Barreda places Soriano within a context of his fellow artists:In fact, this diminutive devil is a friend and contemporary of [Ricardo] Martínez, a kindred spirit of Frida Kahlo, [Agustín] Lazo, [Rufino] Tamayo, [Carlos] Mérida and other principal inhabitants of the subterranean worlds. [He is] of frail stature, somewhat short and thin, with a long nose; with skin and hair dyed to an almost-imperceptible old gold, skittish in the manner of a strange bird, perhaps, one of Disney's woodpeckers.20The introductory paragraphs of this biographical sketch, while seemingly jocular, actually reveal several significant points about the artist. The first is, of course, the impression of his physical state ("diminutive," "frail"), with the addition of his mischievous (or even devilish) qualities. Many essays on the personality and art of Soriano written between the late 1930s and the mid-1940s emphasize his youth, and he is often referred to as a "child." This is not surprising, as he began to exhibit at age fourteen. More importantly, though, Barreda gingerly inserts Soriano within the artistic camp opposed to the politically and socially engaged art that characterized Mexican muralism and its principal proponents, and links him instead to some of the main protagonists of the various countermovements that had begun to assert themselves in the later 1930s and 1940s. Artists such as Tamayo and Martínez practiced a type of figuration mostly devoid of the facile trappings of mexicanidad ("Mexican-ness") that characterized much of the visual production of the so-called Mexican School.21 By associating the names of Kahlo, Lazo, and Mérida with Soriano, Barreda connects all of them to a particular type of painting in Mexico in the first half of the 1940s, which is often related to Surrealism. Four years before Barreda wrote his description of Soriano, the Mexican poet and essayist Octavio Paz published his own evocation of the young man. Paz's essay, one of many he would write about Soriano, was certainly not the first to concentrate on the accomplishments of the youthful artist, but in his text he employed the most lyrical language used to date to describe his achievements as well as his physical persona: "Light body, made of bones as fragile as the skeletons in the toy shop. . . . Ancient boy, petrified, intelligent, passionate, fantastic, real."22 Paz was twenty-seven years old when he wrote these lines about his friend, who was then only twenty-one. The two met when Paz returned from Spain in 1938, after working for a year for the Republican government as a propagandist during the Spanish Civil War. They remained lifelong friends despite long separations while Paz took on various postings to Mexican embassies abroad.23 It was virtually predestined that some of the strongest relationships Soriano formed in his early years would be with poets, novelists, and playwrights. He has stated that reading novels and attending theatrical performances were among his first passions as a child.24 After Soriano's move to Mexico City in 1935, both literature and his friendships with the members of the group of vanguard poets and essayists known as the Contemporáneos became an integral part of his social and artistic life. Soriano told Elena Poniatowska that
Octavio Barreda (for whom I made a few drawings for El hijo pródigo, which he edited) and [the poet] Xavier Villaurrutia gave me access to their library, and the books taught me new ways of seeing the world. Octavio Barreda explained to me what I didn't know. Poetry took on an immense role in my life, and it has become enormous with time. In the 1930s, I suddenly found in a poem by Villaurrutia or Paz the answer to things in life I didn't understand.25The route of inspiration ran equally in the opposite direction; Paz later remarked that "the influence of Soriano has been decisive not only among painters and sculptors, but also on theater and poetry."26 Theater was of exceptional importance for Soriano, and he did some of his most important ephemeral work for various theatrical companies in Mexico City from the late 1930s until well into the 1950s. Indeed, many of his paintings from the years considered here reflect his engagement with the stage (see The Bartered Bride, 1943, Private Collection; New Paradise: The Little Horses {Los Caballitos}, 1945, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Mexico City; The Burial, 1942, Private collection). His interest in designing sets and costumes for productions of contemporary as well as classical dramas had its origins in his childhood fascination with the theater in his native Guadalajara. As a boy Soriano had been fascinated by puppets and often created his own tiny stages from boxes and cartons. He began to make figures from wax and clay, and, later, as a young man in Mexico City, he continued to foster this element of his creativity. In Guadalajara, the Soriano family lived near the Teatro Principal, which the young boy would often visit to meet the actors and, ultimately, help the stagehands paint flats in exchange for free admission to performances.27 Beginning in 1938 Soriano worked for several theater companies in the capital. In that year he created his first sets, for a production of the classic drama El tejedor de Segovia (The Weaver of Segovia) by the late-sixteenth - early-seventeenth-century Mexican playwright Juan Ruiz de Alarcón at the Teatro del Sindicato de Electrisistas. The following year he began working on scenery and costumes for a variety of (mostly classical) plays at the Teatro Orientación. Among his somewhat older fellow artists (many of whom were associated with the Contemporáneos) who had also worked at this theater earlier in the 1930s were Tamayo, Julio Castellanos, Lazo, and Antonio Ruiz. While working at the Teatro Orientación, Soriano taught life drawing at the Escuela de Pintura y Escultura (called La Esmeralda), whose director was his friend Ruiz.28 At the same time he frequented the ceramics workshop of the Costa Rican-born artist Francisco Zúñiga. The mythological subjects of these early (lost) works echoed his later interest in classical themes that by the 1950s became pervasive in his sculpture (in clay and ultimately bronze) and that continued to be of great importance to Soriano even into old age. Soriano was likewise attracted to the ballet and modern dance that had been flourishing in Mexico since the painter Adolfo Best Maugard designed sets for a folk ballet performed by Ana Pavlova in a Mexico City bullring in 1919.29 By the 1930s there were a number of distinguished Mexican-born choreographers, some of whom became Soriano's friends and subjects of his many portraits done in the late 1930s and throughout the 1940s. Dancers such as Amalia Hernández (founder of the Ballet Folklórico de México) and Ana Mérida also commissioned Soriano to design costumes and sets for their performances. He was equally attracted by the most famous Mexican film stars of the 1940s, becoming particularly friendly with Dolores del Río and María Félix, whose portrait he drew in 1959.30 In the late 1930s and into the 1940s Soriano participated in the meetings of various theatrical, literary, and artistic groups who gathered to discuss their work as well as to drink and gossip at the Café de París on the calle Cinco de Mayo in downtown Mexico City. They would also frequent more low-life bars such as El Tenampa on the calle Obregón, where Henri Cartier-Bresson had photographed his famous series of prostitutes. Most of the participants in these gatherings had been connected in one way or another with the Contemporáneos, including Villaurrutia, Barreda, Salvador Novo, Lazo, Carlos Pellicer, Gilberto Owen, and Rafael Solana. By the time Soriano became identified with the Contemporáneos, the group (which was by no means a cohesive organization) had experienced a number of reconfigurations since its most active phase in the late 1920s. The philosophy of its liberal-minded adherents31 was almost diametrically opposed to that of literary/artistic associations that flourished in the 1920s such as the Estridentistas and ¡30-30!, whose members exalted contemporaneity in their literary and visual images of aggressively "modern" factories, automobiles, and machines, as well as the muralists, centered around the Tres Grandes, who relied on socially charged iconography.32 The Contemporáneos, by contrast, were committed to an experimental, non-nationalistic expression in their works. Some (although by no means all) of the members of the Contemporáneos were gay, and a homoerotic ethos permeated certain examples of their literary and visual production, including that by Soriano. This was an element to which many of their generation took exception, and it represented a point of challenge between the Contemporáneos and other Mexican artists and writers who acclaimed direct or implied representations of heterosexuality as the sine qua non of visual or literary expression.33 Soriano's frank affirmation of his sexuality in his paintings, drawings, writings, and interviews would remain a hallmark of his personality throughout his life.34 While Soriano was candid about sexual matters, he was not necessarily liberal when it came to politics. In 1941 the Institute of Modern Art in Boston organized a traveling exhibition entitled Modern Mexican Painters.35 Among the twenty-three artists included, Soriano was represented by a self-portrait done that same year. In the caption to the illustration in the catalogue, the U.S. art collector and writer MacKinley Helm stated that Soriano is "the favorite new painter of the conservative wing in Mexico,"36 thus contrasting him to the social activists among the muralists and their cohort. Yet Soriano was not alone among his Mexican contemporaries in his aversion to overt political imagery and statements. His growing engagement with "universalist" themes, especially after his move to Rome in 1951, and his cultivation of classically oriented subject matter in his painting and sculpture were analogous to the sensibility of Paz and Tamayo, two men he much admired. Soriano was sympathetic to their conservative stance, which became more marked in all three of them in later decades.
Soriano and His Artistic Circle
Two of the many photographs of Juan Soriano taken by Alvarez Bravo throughout the late 1930s and 1940s are particularly strong indicators of the artist's friendships and activities after he moved to Mexico City in 1935. One of them shows him in a suit, standing against a wall contemplating one of two conch shells hanging by wires. Conch shells figure prominently in some of Soriano's still lifes, as they did in those of such Mexican colleagues as Izquierdo, Tamayo, Siqueiros, and Manuel González Serrano. Their sensuous curves evoke not only the mysteries of the sea but female sexuality. Although the tone of this photo is serious and poetic, given Soriano's bawdy sense of humor it is not inconceivable that he was striking an ironic pose. The setting of this photograph is the patio of the Casa Azul, the childhood home of Frida Kahlo in the Coyoacán district of Mexico City, where she lived with her husband, Diego Rivera. Taken around 1945, at a time when Alvarez Bravo executed a number of important photographs of Kahlo, it attests to the young artist's relationship with the Mexican art world's "power couple."37 While Soriano was not an intimate friend of Rivera (and actually disliked most of his mural paintings, along with Mexican muralism in general), they maintained cordial relations throughout the 1940s.38 As for Kahlo, he stated:
Frida was a victim. She had a terrible problem with her leg, but she had a tremendous personality, like a little child full of life. Later Diego came along and dressed her up in those Tehuana clothes. . . . She was a beautiful person, and she re-invented herself. Diego made her "very Mexican," but those clothes looked wonderful on her. She organized her life very well. She painted all of those pictures which I think are very beautiful.39A photograph of the younger Soriano on the beach is from a series of revealingly intimate, candid images captured by Alvarez Bravo during one of their numerous trips throughout Mexico with his sister Martha, her lover Rebeca Uribe, and others. ("We always had a marvelous time in those little hotels," he recalled; "I began to be seduced by nature, the trees, the sky."40) This example, taken in 1937 at the beach at Chachalacas, near Veracruz, suggests Soriano's constant preoccupation with sketching and drawing. By the time this photograph was taken, Soriano had lived in the Mexican capital for two years. He was at first overwhelmed by the vastness of the metropolis, finding it "gigantic, unapproachable, and very mysterious,"41 but accommodated to its pace and quickly made friends from virtually all social classes. His first residence was in a small apartment owned by his maternal aunt Inés. Later, his sister Martha moved to Mexico City, as did his parents and other family members, and he was able to live with them in more hospitable circumstances in an apartment on the calle Bucareli. Almost as soon as he arrived in Mexico City, Soriano became a teacher, giving art classes to working-class students at the Escuela para Obreros. One of the other teachers with whom the sixteen-year-old painter maintained a relationship was Santos Balmori. Aside from giving Soriano informal lessons, he was also influential in introducing him to an organization that played a short-lived but pivotal role in the Mexican cultural scene of the mid-1930s. The LEAR, or Liga de Escritores y Artistas Revolucionarios, was a meeting and exhibition space, artists' and writers' collective, and organization for social action. It existed between 1934 and 1938, and its founding members included Siqueiros, the printmaker Leopoldo Méndez, the composer Silvestre Revueltas, and the Estridentista poet Germán List Arzubide. Soriano was undoubtedly interested in exhibiting with them because the membership included many of his friends from Guadalajara, such as Alvarez Bravo, Chávez Morado, Izquierdo, and Guerrero Galván. Soriano participated in one LEAR exhibition in 1936, but considered the experience a fiasco. He resigned immediately, stating that he found the organization's membership rules and social activist stance "virtually fascistic," and vowing that he would never join another group--whether artistic or political-- and he never did.42 However, the LEAR exhibition, in the deconsecrated church of Santa Clara, proved to offer more opportunities for him than he realized. A few days after the opening a major review appeared in the newspaper Hoy. Written by film director Chano Urueta, it extolled the talents of Soriano, stating that the young artist would "surely become one of our most representative painters." This lengthy article was accompanied by only one illustration, that of the single oil painting in the show by Soriano--Girl with the Head of a Monkey (Private collection)--described as possessing "a profound, subjective beauty, an unknown esoteric attractive quality."43 Thus despite his dismay at the exhibition of what he termed "la horrible LEAR," Soriano critically stole the show and was launched onto the Mexican art scene as a true enfant prodigue.44 Soriano said of his portraits of the 1930s that he desired to create exact depictions of the sitters, not psychologically charged images of them. He described the Portrait of Rebeca Uribe with the Eye of Martha (Fundación Juan Soriano y Marek Keller A.C., Mexico City) as an homage to the painter Mario Alonso (a favorite of the Contemporáneos), who worked "in the Oriental style, very similar to Balinese art." He also admitted a fondness for early Renaissance Florentine drawings and consciously appropriated their crisp, linear style.45 This painting is, on all counts, a strange, enigmatic image. Rebeca Uribe and Soriano's sister lived together at the time. She is dressed in a rose-colored tunic that appears sculpted rather than painted.46 Spiky leaves, resembling spindly fingers, form a nettle-like background separating her from the sky. These carefully painted sinuous plant forms, adding a somewhat dream-like atmosphere to the scene, remind us of the otherworldly still lifes of Soriano's fellow painter González Serrano.47 The sitter's features are painstakingly etched, especially her carefully plucked brows that rise high above her eyes. Her left hand protrudes from her garment and holds the form of an eye. This adds a bizarre touch to the picture and begs an explanation. Could this be a reference to an actual eye, or to the infamous scene in the then-popular 1929 Surrealist film Un Chien Andalou by Luis Buñuel and Salvador Dalí, in which a straight razor is used to split open a woman's eye? More likely, however, this eye is actually a painting within a painting, an example of the artistic tradition of eye portraiture. These are small, cameo-like pictures, often painted on ivory, bearing the image of the eye of a beloved, serving as a constant reminder of the part of the body known as the window to the soul. Eye portraiture, which originated in Europe in the eighteenth century (and possibly earlier), was still being practiced in Mexico in the mid-twentieth century, and it would have been logical for an intimate friend of Martha Soriano to own such an object.48 The Portrait of Rebeca Uribe also testifies to Soriano's continued interest in nineteenth-century Mexican provincial portraiture, as typified by the work of José María Estrada and others (including many anonymous artists) that he had come to know in Guadalajara. In 1943 the painter and critic Ramón Gaya underlined this affinity, remarking that "the work of Soriano is as primitive as that of Estrada. They both have the same concept of [portrait] painting. . . . They felt it to be like the veil of Veronica, quietly caressing the face."49 The type of highly refined, somewhat stiff , and hieratic images painted by Estrada and his contemporaries in Jalisco, Querétaro, Puebla, and elsewhere in nineteenth-century Mexico is well represented by the anonymous Portrait of the Condesa de Canal (1969-273-1) in the Philadelphia Museum of Art. This picture offers a telling contrast to Soriano's portrait of Rebeca Uribe.50 While obviously not a direct precedent for the 1937 work, this likeness (possibly from Guadalajara) displays an elegant woman posed against a minimal background. The noble woman in this portrait also grasps an unusual (for the time) object--a diminutive cigarette. Because nineteenth-century women usually smoked only in the privacy of their homes, this tiny element, like Martha's eye, attests to the intimate nature of the work. The heritage of nineteenth-century Mexican portraiture is also felt in Soriano's Portrait of Rafael Solana of 1938 (Fundación Juan Soriano y Marek Keller A.C., Mexico City). Solana, a poet, novelist, and playwright who was Soriano's friend and traveling companion (in 1938 they made a trip together to San Francisco, the painter's first foreign journey), was closely associated with the Contemporáneos. Soriano stated that he found his friend (who aspired to be a bullfighter as well as a man of letters) to be "somewhat old-fashioned" and accordingly painted him in an out-of-date costume.51 The mannered portrait is placed within a highly expressive nighttime setting, which Soriano later described as being "unlike anything I had previously done."52 After his critical success with the LEAR exhibition in 1936, Soriano went on to participate in numerous group shows in Mexico City and elsewhere in Mexico. The notices were uniformly favorable. They consistently stressed the intensity of the work as well as its "Mexican" character (something that may have irked the artist, who professed a deep aversion to any "typical" elements in his painting). One of the more compelling reviews (both for its praise of the artist and for its own poetic style) appeared in the journal Romance on August 15, 1940. Written by Lorenzo Valera, it assessed the Exposición Hispano-Mexicana at the Librería de Cristal (one of the several bookshops in Mexico City that displayed contemporary art), in which Soriano participated along with a number of émigré painters who had fled the Spanish Civil War (a group with whom the artist had many important friendships in the 1940s). Among the Spaniards were Enrique Climent, Ramón Gaya, and Antonio Rodríguez Luna. Soriano, along with the venerable Dr. Atl (Gerardo Murillo), formed the Mexican contingent. Valera wrote:
The pictures of Juan Soriano appear to have been painted after an excess of fever and they express an intimate condition, the very soul of the painter. It would seem then as if the painter were ill. . . . He appears . . . imprisoned within a strange personal anxiety, far from the world, lost in the most remote origins of his existence, and therefore completely distant from the gaze of others.53One year later the critic José Luis Martínez described the work in Soriano's first one-artist show at the Galería Universitaria (the art gallery of the national university) as "expressing his world, speaking to us simply in an intimate Mexican voice."54 Martínez's essay is especially interesting for its identification of the artist's principal concerns: "He does not paint, nor does he pretend to illustrate social themes, and he is not interested in drawing as a pure plastic amusement. . . . His painting evidences three themes: eroticism, religiosity, and death, whose expression comes about with the intimate sensibility of the Mexican."55 Although Soriano had met Inés Amor, director of the Galería de Arte Mexicano, shortly after arriving in Mexico City in 1935 (the same year Inés's sister Carolina founded the gallery), he did not have a solo show there until March 1945 (sandwiched between exhibitions in February of the Austrian Surrealist Wolfgang Paalen and in April of his fellow Guadalajara artist Raúl Anguiano, who was also working at this time in a semi-Surrealist mode).56 Soriano's second one-artist show at Amor's gallery took place in October 1947. On November 6 of that year a review of the show by Jorge Juan Crespo de la Serna in the influential conservative daily Excélsior was provocatively entitled "Mundo pagano y demoníaco de Juan Soriano" (Pagan and Demonic World of Juan Soriano).57 Still-life paintings formed a significant component of Soriano's work during this period. The roots of his interest in still life are found in his native Jalisco and other provinces of central Mexico, where an active group of nineteenth-century still-life artists (including Agustín Arrieta and Carlos Villaseñor) had produced works that evidenced their (mostly second- or third-hand) knowledge of European (principally Dutch and Flemish) still-life painting while possessing their own disarming directness.58 Soriano would have had ample opportunity to see such pictures in Chucho Reyes's collection in Guadalajara. In addition, these modest paintings were often found in the bourgeois homes of his childhood. Soriano's own still lifes of the late 1930s and 1940s range from direct and quietly poetic images to eerily bizarre compositions. Two still lifes from 1942 and 1946 in the Philadelphia Museum of Art (1951-120-4 and 1957-94-1) are appealing studies of form and color. The 1942 Still Life is dominated by pinks and reds, its lush pink cloth forming a dramatic background for the lilies, carnations, and pomegranates on the tabletop. By contrast, the 1946 Girl with Bouquet represents (with the exception of the blue wall behind the figure) a study in varying tones of white, from the luxurious textile draped across the table to the child's dress and the flowers in a vase. Two other striking examples evoke more questions and are more disturbing for their unusual contents. In the 1938 Still Life with Insect (Fundación Juan Soriano y Marek Keller A.C., Mexico City) a large roll of seemingly brittle, cracked paper is tipped up at an improbable angle on a black tabletop. A small group of dried flowers, a key, and a very large insect that has landed on one of the dried leaves appear to float above the scroll. Such improbable juxtapositions and the instability of the work's components enhance the disorientation experienced by the viewer. The 1941 Still Life with Vase and Skull (Fundación Juan Soriano y Marek Keller A.C., Mexico City) crosses the boundary into the realm of a dream. On a window ledge, at the left, are a glass with two marbles and a large hat pin. Bisecting the surface is a sheaf of wheat next to which is a human skull covered with a diaphanous blue-green cloth. While the presence of the skull immediately calls to mind memento mori iconography of traditional European still lifes, its references to death and the obvious strangeness of the juxtapositions of objects also compel us to consider the artist's relationship to Surrealism, a mode of vision, thought, and literary expression that had a complex history in Mexico City in the late 1930s and early 1940s.59 In another still life that offers a compelling grouping of unusual subjects, the artist places himself at the center of the composition. The 1949 Still Life with Self-Portrait (Fundación Juan Soriano y Marek Keller A.C., Mexico City) combines ears of colored corn, several glass paperweights, a small enamel sculpture of a growling Chinese dog, a bottle with a miniature scene of the crucifixion of Christ, as well as a glass beaker reflecting the artist at his easel. Soriano's interest in Northern Renaissance and Baroque painting is suggested here, and this device calls to mind similar reflections in the work of Jan van Eyck and Johannes Vermeer. Some of Soriano's still lifes also include images of children, who play a substantial role in the artist's work of the 1940s. Soriano's children are far from the stereotypical urban working-class or rural peasant youths depicted in works by his more socially engaged contemporaries. They also exhibit little affiliation with the idealized babies or adolescents painted by colleagues such as Guerrero Galván. By contrast, Soriano's children are often unruly, misbehaving, fighting, or about to get into some other form of trouble. Take the party-dressed young blond girl in the Untitled (Two Children) of 1942 (Private collection). She has just finished sliding down the long banister of a pink adobe house while a toddler (her baby brother?), wearing only a red shirt, struggles to upright himself. The girl has a slightly sinister look on her face, and the artist may be suggesting that she has just pushed the boy down the steps. The art historian Teresa del Conde noted a parallel between Soriano's paintings of adolescents and those of Balthus in their "perverse innocence."60 While he certainly may have been familiar with Balthus's work through reproduction and may well have been influenced by it, Soriano's girls seem more seriously rebellious than the French painter's passive Lolitas. The 1942 Black Table (Private collection), another assembly of incongruously grouped elements, comprises small glass spheres, light bulbs, glass containers, a vase with flowers, the broken head of a colonial statue, and a human skull. Despite the attractions of these objects, the children located below the table (the girl dressed in red, the slightly older boy naked) hold our gaze more directly. The scowling little girl runs away from the boy, who grasps a small wooden toy. He has obviously frightened her in their sinister game of hide-and-seek. The 1941 gouache Child with Bird (Museum of Modern Art, New York, 792.1942) depicts an even more mischievous youth. This somewhat disconcerting image portrays a two- or three-year-old boy standing before a white sheet, as if on display in a (perverse) pantomime. The theatrical aura of the scene is enhanced by his red jacket and odd, conical cap. The boy, nude except for these garments, displays a slight smirk on his face as he grabs the small bird with his right hand, pointing to it with his left. The bird is placed directly in front of his penis. As the slang expression in Spanish for the male genitals derives from a variant of the word for "bird," it becomes obvious that this image portrays a reference to precocious sexual activity. More enigmatic still is the dreamily lyrical Children Playing of 1944 (Museo Andrés Blaisten, Mexico City ), in which two girls appear to be adorning the wall behind them for some festive or religious event. The bulk of the space is taken up by the large tabletop, which features a conch shell, the overturned face of a plaster cast, flowers, and a strange white enamel hand with one raised finger pointing ominously to something outside the picture. The eeriness of this composition is enhanced by the effects of the rain on the window. Two handprints are seen on the glass, and, if we look closely, there appears to be the ghostly profile of a person outlined against the sky. While it may not necessarily be labeled as a Surrealist composition, this appealingly anxiety-filled canvas certainly makes a bow in the direction of dream-related realism, which would play an increasingly important role in Soriano's art of the 1940s.


